When choosing the best knife for your situation you should pay particular attention to the type of steel as well as the edge and even blade shape. Your steel is a critical element of how that blade is going to keep an edge and perform in the situations you need it for. Steel is an alloy (combination of at least one metal and a nonmetal combined) of carbon and iron that is enriched with other elements to improve certain characteristics dependent upon the application desired.
Carbon Steel vs Stainless Steel
Carbon Steel
Very little Chromium
More likely to rust
Harder, retains sharpness better
Best for outdoor applications
Stainless Steel
At least 10.5% Chromium
Rust resistant
Softer, harder keeping an edge
Best for kitchen application
Let’s Talk Hardness Here…
Hardness or (HRC) refers the steels resistance to heat, stress and other forces regularly being applied to knives. The ability for the steel to retain its original shape is measured by the Rockwell C scale. A blade must have the hardness of at least 52 to be able to be considered usable. General knife steel falls in between 58 & 62 HRC range.
Keep in mind… the harder the knife steel, the more challenging it will be to sharpen.
- 52-54: Soft, but decent quality.
- 54-56: General hardness for kitchen knives. Easy to sharpen, but requires regular sharpening.
- 56-58: Typical for premium kitchen knives. Stays sharp longer and easy to sharpen.
- 58-60: Usual hardness for pocket knives such as Spyderco and Cold Steel, or premium Japanese kitchen knives. Retain sharpness for much longer, can be difficult to sharpen.
- 60-62: Blades with this hardness remain sharp for extended periods of time, but can be a challenge to sharpen. They often become brittle.
Typical Steel Types
1065 Steel
(Not a stainless steel)
– tough steel, medium edge durability, resistant to wear and easy to sharpen.
Popular for swords and large knives.
54 – 60 HRC
440 Steel
(Stainless Steel)
– resistant to corrosion, high strength, great edge retention.
58 HRC
D2
(Not a stainless steel)
– very durable, long lasting edge retention, great hardness.
55 -62 HRC
Steel Elements and Key Features
Element:
Carbon
Chromium
Molybdenum
Nickel
Vanadium
Cobalt
Manganese
Silicon
Niobium
Tungsten
Sulfur
Phosphorus
Nitrogen
Features:
Hardness, Edge Retention
Corrosion Resistance, Hardness
Toughness
Toughness
Hardenability, Wear Resistance
Hardness
Hardenability, Strength, Wear Resistance
Hardenability, Strength
Toughness, Wear Resistance, Corrosion Resistance
Toughness, Wear Resistance
Machinability
Hardness, Corrosion Resistance
Hardness, Corrosion Resistance
A premium steel doesn’t necessarily denote a better blade. Just like a lower grade steel does not always mean a low quality blade.
Test your knife for your purpose. Don’t worry about all the science!
Leave a Reply